Korean Hanbok vs Japanese Kimono – Epic Dress Battles of History

0 Posted by - January 28, 2013 - Uncategorized

Hanbok Post-3

What is a Hanbok? 

 A hanbok is a traditional Korean dress.  Throughout Korean history, commoners wore the hanbok and it became popularized during the celebrated Joseon Dynasty.  Interestingly, the hanbok was adopted from nomadic cultures in northern Asia, so its style is drastically different from the formal wear adopted by agricultural cultures like China.    Although the style of the hanbok evolved over time, Koreans still wear the hanbok for formal or semi-formal events like festivals, celebrations, special family events, weddings or first birthdays.

 What is a Kimono?

The Japanese traditional formal wear is known as a kimono.  There are some Japanese who dress in a kimono every day, but the kimono is usually reserved for special events like tea ceremonies or weddings.  When I traveled to Kyoto and Nara, however, I saw far more kimonos being worn than I’ve seen hanboks while living in Seoul.  Nonetheless, it’s not uncommon to see either being worn in their respective countries.  The Kimono was heavily influenced by the hanfu (Chinese traditional dress) of the Han Dynasty of China.  In time, the Kimono also underwent several changes.

 The Battle of the Traditional Dress Styles

Koreans and the Japanese do not share a heartwarming history of friendship and tolerance.  In fact, Koreans still resent Japan for subjecting Korea to brutal colonialism in the first half of the 20th century.  The manifestations of this resentment are apparent in Korea’s zealous persistence for the territorial rights to three rocks with some fish (Dokdo Island) east of the Korean Peninsula.

Furthermore, while Americans are finally aware of some South Korean culture (regrettably through Gangnam Style), those of us in Asia know that the K-wave (Korean dramas and pop music or Hallyu Wave) has consistently dominated the airwaves in Asia for many years.  One could argue that Japan is losing ground.

But for now, it’s time for the most important fight of all.  Which country has the most beautiful traditional clothing?  Kimonos and hanboks are both full of vibrant color and carry the significance of wonderful traditions.  However, only one can be the winner.

The dresses in all of the photographs are within a similar price range.  There are versions of the Kimono which cost over a thousand dollars which I did not include in the pictures.  I included pictures of the dresses you are most likely to see when visiting Japan or Korea.

The pictures of kimonos were taken during my visit to Japan.  Since it was summertime, most of my Kimono pictures are actually pictures of Yukatas- a cheaper, casual version of the Kimono.  On the other hand, my friend, Silvia Conedera, modeled for the photographs of the hanbok.  She commissioned me to photograph her in her hanbok before she left Korea to study fashion in Colombia.  Haley and I will miss her after she leaves, but we’re happy she’s pursuing her dreams.

The Hanbok

Hanbok Post-13

Hanbok Post-8

Hanbok dress

Hanbok dress

Hanbok Post-4

Hanbok Post-10

Hanbok Post-7

Hanbok Post-12

Hanbok Post-6

The Kimono/Yukata

Kyoto Pictures-1

Hanbok Post-22

Hanbok Post-20

Hanbok Post-21

  • http://www.facebook.com/bobbymc Bobby McGill

    The Kimono gets the nod from me. Great shots.

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com brentdsheffield

      Oooh. Well, it’s not like you have a magazine in Korea.

  • Silvia

    I have to get a Kimono next. Then I will have a dress from all the mayor countries in Asia. :)

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com brentdsheffield

      You looked sexy, don’t worry! My girlfriend got mad every time I told you you were pretty.

  • http://www.monkeyboygoes.com monkeyboygoes

    I’ll have to go for the Kimono also. Much more sexier!

  • terryleesheffield

    First of all, I love all traditions! Love the Kimono but adore the hanbok. Love Silvia, her shoes and bag! The cup of tea she is holding makes me want a cup right now. I also am very fond of the writer and photographer of this article. : )

  • http://seoulstateofmind.wordpress.com kenlumlee

    BOTH! However a Kimono looks better when holding a samurai sword =)

    Amazing portrait shots.

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com brentdsheffield

      Thanks Ken! You know I’m a fan of your work!

  • http://twitter.com/columbine75 Andrea Longman (@columbine75)

    Beautiful pictures of a beautiful model – I’d never heard of a hanbok – she looks lovely.

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com Brent Sheffield

      She is lovely! I’ll miss her! She’ll be a great addition to the fashion world.

  • Pingback: Korean Gender Reader, 26 Jan. – 1 Feb. | The Grand Narrative

  • Regina

    Your friend is cute, but is it really fair to compare one style of hanbok with multiple styles of kimono?

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com Brent Sheffield

      Only if you take the post way too seriously….besides, the Hanbok got a professional shoot from me, the kimono’s were random vacation shots.

      I vote for the Hanbok!

  • http://gravatar.com/jenhime Jenny

    I don’t understand why one countries traditional dress is better then the other, both hanbok and kimono are beautiful in their own way. And in the kimono pictures only the first picture is of kimonos, the rest are simple cotton robes called yukata worn in the summer especially at festivals. (I know I wear and own a small collection of kimono)

  • jennyhime

    I don’t understand why there should be a competition of which traditional outfit is more pretty, both are very beautiful.
    And in the kimono pictures, only the first picture is of kimono. The rest are yukata, cotton robes worn only in summer at festivals or at traditional Japanese inns. (I have a small collection of kimono and know how to wear them)

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com Brent Sheffield

      I don’t think you should take people’s opinions about which dress is prettier to heart. It’s just for fun. But, it’s definitely not politically correct to post the same thing twice.

  • jennyhime

    It was by accident, it said comment not posted and the second time it went through. (it does it sometimes)
    If it’s for fun then okay but it still sounded a bit like costume x is better then costume y because…..
    Both hanboks (modernized and traditional especially the type worn by kisaeng’s) are stunning as is kimono with seasonal patterns and elements.

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com Brent Sheffield

      I agree. I was teasing about the second post. It happens to the best of us;)

  • Erika

    I don’t want to be picky, buut the pictures you posted are all “Yukata”, they are a lighter, easier to wear and especially cheaper version of Kimono worn mostly for summer festivals. We wear Kimono for momentous ocassion like Seijinshiki (coming of age), graduation or weddings : ) (i.e.: http://myfurisode.com/vote/list ) it’s a big difference in material quality, patterns and pirce. You can buy a full Yukata set for 50~100$. to buy a Kimono… 1000$ minimum.. most people will rent everything for 250~400$ a day..! I think if you want a fair “battle” you should compare Hanbok with real Kimono, not Yukata. : )

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com Brent Sheffield

      Noted- this was never a super serious post, it was kind of a joke to show off my photographs of my friend. The Hanbok is not 1000 dollars so I think I included dresses within a comparable price range. However, I updated the post with some of your information. Thanks!

      • Erika

        No Problem! : ) Your Pictures are very very nice and your friend is super cute! If you go to Japan again, you can take a lot of kimono pictures in spring when people celebrating coming of age walk the towns

        • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com Brent Sheffield

          I hope I can. I loved Japan.

  • Rita

    I got many yukata’s and eyeing hanbok for a looong time, yukata much easier to get while hanbok soo much hassle due to measurement (you need exact body measurement to buy them)..

  • http://lovingkorean.com oegukeen

    I think Kimono is more well known in the western world. I’ve never heard of Hanbok until I met my Korean boyfriend. Also, I think Westerner are more used to a dress accentuating female curves so Kimono might be more familiar to us, but Hanbok has it’s beauty as well.

  • JEFFREY ANG

    Kimono or more accurately Wafuku might look very nice, but it is extremely complex to wear and tie. Even when you tie the OBI (belt) for yukata (summer robe), you still need the skill to do so. My Japanese cousin in Yamagata even need three of her friends to help her to wear a FULL FLEDGE (fully attired formal) furisode kimono on the new year day. It took her at least 45 minutes to do so. Or else she might have to spend USD250 (minimum) to hire a kimono attire licensed expert to help her to wear the new year kimono. Furthermore, when you wear a kimono (for female), you cannot walk with big steps no matter what you think, you cannot simply walk the way you like to walk. It’s beautiful but yet a bit torturing to wear and move in kimono. Hanbok might be not so sophisticated as kimono, hanbok might not comes with so many accessories like kimono or wafuku, but at least Hanbok is much more comfortable, it’s not so tight, you don’t have to walk in small steps and most importantly much much more easier to wear. Sorry to say that, but for plus sized ladies, hanbok is a better choice.

  • JEFFREY ANG

    One more thing. On average kimono or wafuku are much much more expensive than hanbok, even a decent and simple yukata (summer robe) will cost you easily USD100-200++. My Japanese counsin full set furisode kimono cost her USD8500++ (excluding GST) it is made with fully nishijin silk/textile together with all the accessories (excluding the head accessories), she spent another USD300 for her sterling silver (with pearls and simple jade piece) and gold plated hairpin/accessories.

  • http://Google Yaya

    I like kimono cuz hanbok make u look pregnant while kimono make u look young and beautiful !!

  • Masaki

    I pick Kimono/Wafuku, my family are kinda “traditional” and every festivals/matsuri we wear Kimonos. Kimono looks more sophisticated and men’s kimonos are really good too.

  • hikari

    i m falling in love with hanbok. although i am studying in jpan and can speak japanese. compare to yukata, it is easier to wear hanbok. how much it cost?

  • Emily Myers

    I am also a huge fan of hanbok! Absolutely enjoyed reading your post, except that I had to point out something for you and many people who would get a wrong insight of Dokdo. I am from america and now studying Oriental history in an university in tohoku, japan. I have deeply researched about this island.
    Dokdo as an inherent territory of Korea has been under effective control of Korea since Japan defeated in the WW2. Dokdo is the small, uninhabited island which Imperial Japan illegally incorporated into Japanese land in 1905. After Japan lost the WW2, Dodko was returned to Korea according to SF Treaty because it was the land Japan took from Korea by greed and violation.Dokdo is just a part of Korea which Korean peoples are living. Japanese claiming “Dokdo(Takeshima) is Japanese land.” is like Japanese claiming “Korea is Japanese land because we colonized it before.” “Korea is Japanese land.” sounds very nonsense, doesn’t it? Claiming “Dokdo(Takeshima) is Japanese land.” is nonsense as much as “Korea is Japanese land.”I hope you understand the real situation related on Dokdo.

    • http://kimchibytes.wordpress.com Brent Sheffield

      Agree with the views of Dokdo

    • Whi-Inh Bae

      Thank you! Finally someone who understands…

      • http://kimcihbytes.com Brent Sheffield

        I would love for someone to write an Entire post on this subject. I don’t know enough although I’m also convinced that Dokdo is Korean. Please understand the post above for jus fun and not serious.

      • http://kimcihbytes.com Brent Sheffield

        I’d love for someone to submit a post on Dokdo Island.

    • yj

      thank you so much for your understanding! I am so glad that someone knows the right knowledge. She looks so beautiful wearing HANBOK. sooooo beautiful :)

  • Tiffany

    Actually, hanbok was also heavily influenced by Hanfu. There are many types of Hanfu and this being one that the Hanbok resembles the closest
    http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-yng8vBvWQDo/TwE_HwaBtLI/AAAAAAAAAFk/f3efUU93fcI/s1600/hanfu-+han3.jpg

  • Ng Yaozheng

    I vote for Hanfu.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers:

%d bloggers like this: